2-14-2016 Banded Results BCR Test



• Name: the name of the matrix (test)
• N: the dimension of the matrix (number of rows and columns)
• NNZ: number of non-zeros
• SPD: whether the matrix is specified by the user to be symmetric positive definite (values: 0 or 1)
• DB: indicate whether DB reordering is performed. Values: 0 or 1.
• K-DB: the half-bandwidth after DB reordering method (without any drop-off). If DB is specified not to be executed, then this reports the original half-bandwidth
• KnoDrp: the half-bandwidth after DB and CM reordering but before drop-off
• K: the half-bandwidth after reordering and drop-off
• FRate: fill-in rate. See NOTES below
• nuKf: non-uniform K factor. Indicates whether the K changes a lot from row to row. Values are between 0 and 1, with 0 indicating a perfectly uniform bandwidth over the entire matrix. See NOTES below
• Solves: indicates whether we managed to solve the problem or not. OK means solved fine, otherwise a reason is provided for failure
• Bstng: indicates whether we enable diagonal boosting when doing factorization. Values: 0 or 1
• SolAcc: infinity norm of the array storing the relative errors
• T-DB: time to run DB reordering for the matrix on the CPU
• T-CM: time to run CM reordering for the matrix on the CPU
• T-Drop: time to drop off off-diagonal elements to decrease bandwidth. Done on the CPU.
• T-Dtransf: data transfer from CPU to GPU
• T-Asmbl: after reordering and drop-off, copy the sparse matrix to banded matrix stored in GPU memory
• LU-M: LU method (complete, ILUT or ILUULT)
• Fill-in: the fill-in factor of ILUT (-1 indicates complete LU)
• NPrtns: the number of partitions used to solve the problem
• T-BC: time required to get off-diagonal right hand sides (Bs and Cs) from the banded matrix - done on the GPU
• T-LU: LU time
• GFlps-LU: LU GFLOPs
• T-SPK: time to solve for the spikes Vs and Ws - done on the GPU
• T-LUrdcd: time required to factorize the reduced matrices - done on the GPU
• T-PreP: the sum of all preprocessing times, see NOTES
• Kry-M: the method used in Krylov solving stage (can be BiCGStab2 (0), BiCGStab (1), or CG(2))
• nItrs: the number of Krylov-solve iterations to solve the problem
• T-Kry: time spent in the Krylov solver (on the GPU)
• Total: total time to solve the problem, sum of PreProc + T-Kry
• Pardiso: the time for the commercial tool "Pardiso" to solve the problem
• SlwD: the slowdown ratio of our solver compared to Pardiso (a value less than one means that we are faster than Pardiso. The value is shown in green if we run faster and shown in red if we run more than 5 times slower.)
• Fastest: the time when SaP runs fastest historically
• SpdUp: the speedup of this run compared to the historical fastest run (the value is shown in green if the speedup is more than 5% and shown in red if the slowdown is more than 5%)


NOTES:
1) nuKf = 1/(2KN)*[sum over i from 1 to N of (2K - K_{iLeft} - K_{iRight})], where K_{iLeft} is the row half-bandwidth to the left of the diagonal while K_{iRight} is the row half-bandwidth to the right of the diagonal.
2) FRate = the actual number of NNZ / ((2K+1)N).
3) All times reported are in miliseconds (1E-3 second)


N

K

d

NPrtns

Solves

T-LU

T-SwDef

T-MMDef

T-PreP

nItrs

T-SwInf

T-MVInf

T-Kry

T-KryPIt

T-Total

500000

10

1

1

OK

53.8724

56.4267

64.8508

197.035

0.25

14.6816

45.6939

73.926

73.926

270.961

500000

10

0.8

1

OK

53.9618

56.4949

65.1312

197.527

0.25

14.6997

45.7207

74.09

74.09

271.617

500000

10

0.6

1

OK

43.2746

56.4231

63.7592

185.001

0.25

14.6253

45.5681

73.529

73.529

258.53

500000

10

0.4

1

OK

44.0081

56.475

63.6468

185.732

0.25

14.6371

45.5918

73.625

73.625

259.357

500000

10

0.2

1

OK

53.8654

56.4024

64.7786

197.021

1.75

43.9873

137.015

217.61

124.349

414.631

500000

10

0.1

1

OK

43.1654

56.4125

63.6956

184.839

0.75

24.358

75.9328

121.636

121.636

306.475

500000

10

0.08

1

OK

53.7958

56.4284

64.0486

196.161

0.75

24.3646

75.951

121.66

121.66

317.821

500000

10

0.06

1

OK

43.3242

56.3633

64.6908

186.047

0.75

24.3431

75.9314

121.547

121.547

307.594

500000

10

0.04

1

OK

42.0862

56.3603

63.3171

183.192

0.75

24.306

75.8905

121.36

121.36

304.552

500000

10

0.02

1

OK

43.3442

56.4398

64.3934

185.721

0.75

24.3511

75.93

121.614

121.614

307.335

500000

10

0.01

1

OK

53.8387

56.4292

64.9084

197.147

0.75

24.4338

76.1236

122.142

122.142

319.289

500000

10

1

2

OK

51.6818

56.4466

63.4224

193.573

2.75

62.8358

196.336

309.266

112.46

502.839

500000

10

1

2

OK

27.0172

29.0092

48.0869

142.304

2.75

34.5487

101.796

196.397

71.4171

338.701

500000

10

0.8

2

OK

42.0012

56.3635

62.9596

182.827

3.25

72.4228

226.38

355.352

109.339

538.179

500000

10

0.8

2

OK

25.6635

29.2911

51.1473

127.76

3.25

40.2266

119.096

228.903

70.4317

356.663

500000

10

0.6

2

OK

52.1363

56.4199

64.1352

194.538

3.25

82.3935

257.205

403.774

124.238

598.312

500000

10

0.6

2

OK

30.116

29.2838

48.9364

139.29

3.25

45.7689

135.434

258.657

79.5868

397.947

500000

10

0.4

2

OK

50.7032

56.4877

72.5522

201.397

4.25

92.4023

288.098

455.655

107.213

657.052

500000

10

0.4

2

OK

27.2006

28.9735

48.3184

145.876

4.25

50.5053

148.831

285.761

67.2379

431.637

500000

10

0.2

2

OK

51.9425

56.3996

63.3929

193.614

8.25

178.652

558.471

873.149

105.836

1066.76

500000

10

0.2

2

OK

30.3436

28.9527

48.4723

139.796

8.25

98.2066

289.653

552.544

66.975

692.34

500000

10

0.1

2

OK

41.9291

56.4076

63.1338

183.032

9.75

198.024

618.815

968.282

99.311

1151.31

500000

10

0.1

2

OK

30.3659

28.9132

50.5054

153.657

9.75

108.664

320.661

611.845

62.7533

765.502

500000

10

0.08

2

OK

49.2383

56.4712

80.9471

208.627

9.25

189.565

591.026

928.752

100.406

1137.38

500000

10

0.08

2

OK

30.2876

28.9233

48.4632

139.064

9.25

103.479

305.277

582.908

63.0171

721.972

500000

10

0.06

2

OK

52.1294

56.9311

63.7809

194.788

10.25

209.749

658.314

1027.85

100.278

1222.64

500000

10

0.06

2

OK

30.8427

28.9591

49.3178

140.564

10.25

114.819

338.195

646.759

63.0984

787.323

500000

10

0.04

2

OK

42.3477

56.3433

63.1206

183.356

10.75

217.183

679.079

1061.6

98.7532

1244.95

500000

10

0.04

2

OK

26.6136

28.9105

48.7859

138.871

10.75

119.335

352.026

671.73

62.4865

810.601

500000

10

0.02

2

OK

52.5611

57.0156

63.9032

195.458

9.25

200.244

628.1

980.175

105.965

1175.63

500000

10

0.02

2

OK

30.6722

28.9434

48.9163

139.564

9.25

109.344

322.182

615.081

66.4952

754.645

500000

10

0.01

2

OK

42.3473

56.332

63.3416

183.773

10.25

207.523

648.879

1014.33

98.9586

1198.1

500000

10

0.01

2

OK

26.9192

28.922

48.4719

140.054

10.25

114.092

336.535

641.832

62.6178

781.886

500000

20

1

1

OK

72.4923

98.2505

104.87

300.656

0.25

13.8359

49.8028

82.502

82.502

383.158

500000

20

0.8

1

OK

74.8189

99.3248

91.37

290.5

0.25

13.8912

50.3208

81.115

81.115

371.615

500000

20

0.6

1

OK

64.038

98.0766

90.3454

277.126

0.25

13.7319

49.5821

79.974

79.974

357.1

500000

20

0.4

1

OK

63.8211

98.1836

90.3778

277.083

0.25

13.75

49.6001

80.259

80.259

357.342

500000

20

0.2

1

OK

63.6909

98.1688

90.4746

277.038

0.25

13.7359

49.6194

80.113

80.113

357.151

500000

20

0.1

1

OK

74.4546

99.1135

91.8757

290.362

0.75

23.2102

84.0271

134.593

134.593

424.955

500000

20

0.08

1

OK

73.622

97.9789

90.7229

287.247

0.75

22.8966

82.6645

132.451

132.451

419.698

500000

20

0.06

1

OK

63.8315

97.9866

90.617

277.184

0.75

22.8744

82.6417

132.432

132.432

409.616

500000

20

0.04

1

OK

64.2352

99.1557

91.163

279.351

0.75

23.1341

83.8269

134.051

134.051

413.402

500000

20

0.02

1

OK

74.0955

97.9789

91.1876

288.166

1.75

41.3184

149.139

237.06

135.463

525.226

500000

20

0.01

1

OK

63.9117

98.0261

90.3803

277.056

0.75

22.8638

82.633

132.396

132.396

409.452

500000

20

1

2

OK

62.5732

97.7883

89.8663

274.931

2.25

58.8058

214.41

336.899

149.733

611.83

500000

20

1

2

OK

39.5593

51.3626

61.6763

185.806

2.25

33.9971

112.712

221.739

98.5507

407.545

500000

20

0.8

2

OK

69.5606

97.7427

102.971

295.263

2.25

58.9751

214.739

339.675

150.967

634.938

500000

20

0.8

2

OK

36.5357

50.7911

60.0807

187.924

2.25

33.4499

110.817

218.157

96.9587

406.081

500000

20

0.6

2

OK

71.7803

97.8802

90.1401

284.777

2.75

58.8605

214.516

338.285

123.013

623.062

500000

20

0.6

2

OK

36.388

50.7275

59.0996

187.341

2.75

33.4141

110.786

219.066

79.6604

406.407

500000

20

0.4

2

OK

71.8581

97.7518

90.0624

284.956

3.75

76.9147

280.436

441.401

117.707

726.357

500000

20

0.4

2

OK

39.5985

50.7229

59.4134

188.767

3.75

43.861

145.183

286.689

76.4504

475.456

500000

20

0.2

2

OK

61.665

97.6788

89.8134

273.732

7.5

149.271

544.213

853.231

113.764

1126.96

500000

20

0.2

2

OK

39.2863

50.7076

61.0956

188.166

7.5

85.3478

282.349

553.894

73.8525

742.06

500000

20

0.1

2

OK

71.8075

97.5965

89.9808

284.156

17.25

328.975

1202.09

1877.2

108.823

2161.36

500000

20

0.1

2

OK

36.38

50.6476

58.9803

186.97

17.25

187.182

621.575

1212.14

70.2689

1399.11

500000

20

0.08

2

OK

63.2515

98.7777

90.7961

277.709

20.25

378.316

1386.8

2162.41

106.786

2440.12

500000

20

0.08

2

OK

36.5291

50.6687

60.35

187.65

20.25

212.878

706.657

1378.84

68.0907

1566.49

500000

20

0.06

2

OK

67.4667

97.6369

89.7446

279.496

17.25

320.213

1169.56

1827.16

105.922

2106.66

500000

20

0.06

2

OK

36.3658

50.6505

59.7356

187.707

17.25

182.163

604.685

1180

68.406

1367.71

500000

20

0.04

2

OK

72.0049

97.7237

90.0063

284.555

19.25

356.386

1301.64

2032.54

105.586

2317.09

500000

20

0.04

2

OK

39.6471

50.6913

60.1809

187.626

19.25

204.102

675.551

1320.65

68.6054

1508.28

500000

20

0.02

2

OK

62.5917

97.7005

89.8643

274.815

17.75

329.384

1202.81

1879.25

105.873

2154.07

500000

20

0.02

2

OK

37.2642

51.2836

60.5926

188.267

17.75

189.211

630.213

1227.29

69.143

1415.56

500000

20

0.01

2

OK

63.1815

98.8834

90.7702

277.596

19.25

369.376

1353.76

2110.14

109.618

2387.74

500000

20

0.01

2

OK

39.825

50.643

60.4182

188.255

19.25

208.999

692.062

1351.75

70.2208

1540.01

500000

50

1

1

OK

137.414

149.296

192.701

525.924

0.25

16.6123

50.3337

88.092

88.092

614.016

500000

50

0.8

1

OK

147.466

149.272

192.817

536.347

0.25

16.6187

50.3187

88.221

88.221

624.568

500000

50

0.6

1

OK

137.508

149.247

192.762

526.238

0.25

16.6059

50.347

88.093

88.093

614.331

500000

50

0.4

1

OK

137.381

149.098

192.916

526.225

0.25

16.5866

50.291

88.015

88.015

614.24

500000

50

0.2

1

OK

137.211

148.92

192.776

525.608

0.25

16.5962

50.319

87.88

87.88

613.488

500000

50

0.1

1

OK

148.528

150.196

195.122

540.662

1.75

50.399

153.309

264.605

151.203

805.267

500000

50

0.08

1

OK

137.422

148.846

192.659

525.655

0.75

27.65

83.8459

145.914

145.914

671.569

500000

50

0.06

1

OK

146.972

148.859

192.847

535.501

0.75

27.6563

83.8383

145.94

145.94

681.441

500000

50

0.04

1

OK

137.324

148.792

192.558

525.471

0.75

27.6095

83.8278

145.94

145.94

671.411

500000

50

0.02

1

OK

147.045

148.905

192.855

535.561

0.75

27.665

83.8588

145.921

145.921

681.482

500000

50

0.01

1

OK

147.255

148.845

192.747

535.585

0.75

27.6719

83.9201

146.128

146.128

681.713

500000

50

1

2

OK

136.118

148.03

192.037

522.937

1.75

48.8975

150.547

259.184

148.105

782.121

500000

50

1

2

OK

73.6086

78.1067

109.61

333.638

1.75

29.5272

77.7151

174.407

99.6611

508.045

500000

50

0.8

2

OK

144.986

147.966

191.965

531.618

2.25

59.7533

183.887

315.783

140.348

847.401

500000

50

0.8

2

OK

73.4032

78.0788

109.404

333.835

2.25

36.0768

94.9956

211.744

94.1084

545.579

500000

50

0.6

2

OK

144.814

147.923

192.281

531.715

2.25

70.5873

217.279

371.893

165.286

903.608

500000

50

0.6

2

OK

73.46

78.175

109.429

333.569

2.25

42.6741

112.256

249.421

110.854

582.99

500000

50

0.4

2

OK

146.519

148.991

194.311

536.711

3.25

82.0951

254.07

433.979

133.532

970.69

500000

50

0.4

2

OK

76.0307

78.019

108.434

333.674

3.25

49.1891

129.488

287.751

88.5388

621.425

500000

50

0.2

2

OK

145.103

147.952

192.219

531.969

5.25

124.918

384.48

657.563

125.25

1189.53

500000

50

0.2

2

OK

76.1912

78.1782

108.99

334.43

5.25

75.9433

199.275

442.014

84.1931

776.444

500000

50

0.1

2

OK

136.078

147.755

192.132

522.746

27.25

613.63

1889.57

3221.84

118.233

3744.59

500000

50

0.1

2

OK

76.2675

77.9637

108.525

333.913

27.25

373.11

979.184

2162.12

79.3439

2496.03

500000

50

0.08

2

OK

136.158

147.967

191.975

522.867

39.25

873.893

2691.27

4589.3

116.925

5112.17

500000

50

0.08

2

OK

73.4038

78.0615

109.121

333.335

39.25

527.88

1390.16

3063.7

78.0561

3397.03

500000

50

0.06

2

OK

137.532

148.901

194.227

527.434

44.25

990.131

3065.12

5211.02

117.763

5738.45

500000

50

0.06

2

OK

73.242

77.9868

109.433

333.43

44.25

593.405

1562.17

3443.62

77.8219

3777.05

500000

50

0.04

2

OK

144.857

147.727

192.039

531.513

64.25

1406.08

4329.12

7380.44

114.871

7911.95

500000

50

0.04

2

OK

73.7451

78.5325

109.988

334.393

64.25

855.34

2264.33

4969.61

77.3481

5304.01

500000

50

0.02

2

OK

136.165

147.927

191.983

522.696

71.25

1568.84

4830.91

8233.25

115.554

8755.95

500000

50

0.02

2

OK

73.4957

77.9826

109.02

333.369

71.25

946.782

2494.09

5495.72

77.1329

5829.09

500000

50

0.01

2

OK

145.019

147.694

192.305

531.694

86.75

1896.17

5834.89

9950.02

114.698

10481.7

500000

50

0.01

2

OK

76.0554

77.9954

109.283

334.452

86.75

1152.3

3023.15

6667.39

76.8575

7001.84

500000

100

1

1

OK

296.198

527.732

435.951

1375.06

0.25

24.2187

63.0194

120.088

120.088

1495.15

500000

100

0.8

1

OK

292.611

524.045

430.302

1362.15

0.25

24.0428

62.3516

119.429

119.429

1481.58

500000

100

0.6

1

OK

287.349

527.945

435.307

1365.23

0.25

24.1804

62.9339

119.817

119.817

1485.05

500000

100

0.4

1

OK

284.099

524.707

430.375

1354

0.25

24.0466

62.3982

119.277

119.277

1473.27

500000

100

0.2

1

OK

283.591

523.865

430.124

1351.8

0.25

24.0149

62.3546

119.217

119.217

1471.02

500000

100

0.1

1

OK

286.883

527.426

435.325

1364.35

0.25

24.184

62.9329

119.947

119.947

1484.3

500000

100

0.08

1

OK

286.833

527.487

434.745

1363.76

0.75

40.2638

104.87

198.956

198.956

1562.71

500000

100

0.06

1

OK

292.884

523.89

430.477

1361.99

0.75

40.0608

103.894

197.862

197.862

1559.85

500000

100

0.04

1

OK

283.825

523.823

430.694

1353.15

0.75

40.0611

103.883

198.34

198.34

1551.49

500000

100

0.02

1

OK

292.87

523.685

430.771

1362.47

0.75

40.1692

104.02

198.601

198.601

1561.07

500000

100

0.01

1

OK

283.764

523.927

430.108

1352.65

0.75

40.0588

103.896

197.855

197.855

1550.5

500000

100

1

2

OK

290.505

519.598

429.933

1354.62

1.75

70.6149

186.568

352.675

201.529

1707.29

500000

100

1

2

OK

146.758

274.501

226.885

793.75

1.75

43.146

95.575

240.375

137.357

1034.12

500000

100

0.8

2

OK

282.436

519.966

429.783

1347.26

1.75

70.4658

186.446

351.69

200.966

1698.95

500000

100

0.8

2

OK

146.435

274.209

227.582

793.647

1.75

43.1705

95.6016

240.482

137.418

1034.13

500000

100

0.6

2

OK

290.701

520.242

429.755

1355.38

2.25

86.1712

227.908

428.78

190.569

1784.16

500000

100

0.6

2

OK

146.738

274.203

224.587

795.266

2.25

52.7479

116.854

292.583

130.037

1087.85

500000

100

0.4

2

OK

285.486

523.784

434.437

1358.27

2.75

102.317

271.798

510.002

185.455

1868.27

500000

100

0.4

2

OK

146.712

274.822

226.818

793.87

2.75

62.343

138.171

346.175

125.882

1140.05

500000

100

0.2

2

OK

291.022

519.779

430.649

1356.2

3.75

133.448

352.742

663.451

176.92

2019.65

500000

100

0.2

2

OK

146.666

274.171

226.398

793.066

3.75

81.523

180.564

451.719

120.458

1244.79

500000

100

0.1

2

OK

286.872

519.573

437.153

1358.29

7.75

259.286

684.913

1290.42

166.506

2648.71

500000

100

0.1

2

OK

146.358

274.219

226.993

793.299

7.75

158.277

350.503

874.541

112.844

1667.84

500000

100

0.08

2

OK

290.79

519.625

430.113

1355.23

24.25

790.94

2092.09

3917.99

161.567

5273.22

500000

100

0.08

2

OK

146.634

274.077

227.298

793.705

24.25

484.288

1072.36

2670.31

110.116

3464.01

500000

100

0.06

2

OK

290.937

519.814

430.197

1355.52

95.25

3005.71

7945.53

14894.5

156.372

16250

500000

100

0.06

2

OK

149.319

274.211

226.986

794.958

95.25

1842.29

4076.04

10137.9

106.435

10932.9

500000

100

0.04

2

NConv

290.624

519.663

430.328

1355.27

101.25

3193.16

8440.11

15823.9

156.285

17179.2

500000

100

0.04

2

NConv

149.194

274.102

226.876

795.985

101.25

1956.92

4332.42

10786

106.529

11582

500000

100

0.02

2

NConv

290.317

519.664

429.389

1354.18

101.25

3183.39

8426.68

15777.3

155.825

17131.5

500000

100

0.02

2

NConv

148.074

276.162

227.917

796.766

101.25

1963.65

4363.63

10806.7

106.733

11603.5

500000

100

0.01

2

NConv

291.208

519.841

429.969

1355.71

101.25

3185.28

8430.23

15779.1

155.843

17134.8

500000

100

0.01

2

NConv

146.681

274.107

223.833

794.5

101.25

1950.79

4324.01

10749.5

106.168

11544

500000

200

1

1

OK

913.071

1427.2

1156.28

3798.46

0.25

45.8325

88.3886

190.54

190.54

3989

500000

200

0.8

1

OK

905.351

1427.14

1154.16

3788.59

0.25

45.9906

88.4711

191.106

191.106

3979.7

500000

200

0.6

1

OK

913.349

1426.75

1153.34

3794.7

0.25

45.9683

88.4654

190.832

190.832

3985.53

500000

200

0.4

1

OK

914.354

1428.06

1153.96

3797.59

0.25

45.8745

88.4257

190.565

190.565

3988.15

500000

200

0.2

1

OK

913.838

1428.5

1153.69

3799.26

0.25

45.9218

88.4272

190.792

190.792

3990.05

500000

200

0.1

1

OK

905.125

1427.44

1152.95

3787.28

0.25

45.9581

88.4772

191.438

191.438

3978.72

500000

200

0.08

1

OK

905.533

1427.61

1154.05

3788.92

0.25

45.8412

88.3953

190.282

190.282

3979.21

500000

200

0.06

1

OK

913.7

1426.79

1154.57

3798.24

0.25

45.928

88.4995

190.513

190.513

3988.76

500000

200

0.04

1

OK

913.443

1426.26

1154.38

3796.75

0.75

76.4215

147.315

316.464

316.464

4113.21

500000

200

0.02

1

OK

913.714

1427.27

1154

3797.3

0.75

76.5536

147.507

316.953

316.953

4114.25

500000

200

0.01

1

OK

904.85

1425.61

1153.76

3786.29

1.25

107.025

206.203

442.19

353.752

4228.48

500000

200

1

2

OK

903.183

1414.69

1149.7

3769.37

1.75

134.594

264.25

564.091

322.338

4333.46

500000

200

1

2

OK

458.389

742.583

587.993

2113.74

1.75

80.2452

135.168

387.11

221.206

2500.85

500000

200

0.8

2

OK

911.157

1415.23

1150.02

3778.96

1.75

134.733

264.583

565.046

322.883

4344.01

500000

200

0.8

2

OK

460.541

742.848

584.693

2113.51

1.75

80.3074

135.187

387.565

221.466

2501.07

500000

200

0.6

2

OK

910.961

1414.13

1149.79

3776.69

1.75

134.627

264.543

564.965

322.837

4341.66

500000

200

0.6

2

OK

460.555

742.943

584.019

2114.15

1.75

80.371

135.391

388.699

222.114

2502.85

500000

200

0.4

2

OK

910.721

1415.24

1149.14

3777.3

2.25

194.507

381.845

812.238

360.995

4589.54

500000

200

0.4

2

OK

458.093

742.774

586.395

2112.69

2.25

116.007

195.223

558.459

248.204

2671.15

500000

200

0.2

2

OK

921.733

1427.52

1164.43

3815.91

3.25

225.942

444.419

943.726

290.377

4759.64

500000

200

0.2

2

OK

460.607

742.576

585.764

2116.22

3.25

133.812

225.289

643.143

197.89

2759.36

500000

200

0.1

2

OK

911.205

1415.27

1150.01

3778.49

5.25

344.453

676.242

1439.94

274.275

5218.43

500000

200

0.1

2

OK

460.501

742.124

585.774

2116.91

5.25

205.19

345.238

985.497

187.714

3102.41

500000

200

0.08

2

OK

903.182

1414.84

1148.38

3768.77

7.25

493.314

969.119

2060.5

284.207

5829.27

500000

200

0.08

2

OK

458.661

742.311

583

2113.56

7.25

294.372

495.561

1410.92

194.61

3524.49

500000

200

0.06

2

OK

903.475

1414.6

1148.87

3769.52

18.75

1152.76

2263.16

4814.4

256.768

8583.92

500000

200

0.06

2

OK

458.929

742.688

587.705

2116.66

18.75

686.867

1157.18

3297.32

175.857

5413.98

500000

200

0.04

2

NConv

911.553

1416.01

1148.7

3777.91

101.25

6094.12

11968.4

25431.9

251.179

29209.8

500000

200

0.04

2

NConv

460.9

742.095

583.95

2134.06

101.25

3635.73

6116.23

17414.8

171.998

19548.9

500000

200

0.02

2

NConv

904.544

1414.82

1148.93

3771.08

101.25

6095.94

11966.8

25434.8

251.208

29205.9

500000

200

0.02

2

NConv

463.909

749.937

591.092

2122.78

101.25

3656.95

6161.42

17464.1

172.485

19586.9

500000

200

0.01

2

NConv

903.45

1414.69

1148.56

3768.71

101.25

6085.33

11951.2

25380.7

250.674

29149.5

500000

200

0.01

2

NConv

466.672

749.482

592.123

2127.2

101.25

3659.76

6159.88

17476.4

172.606

19603.6

500000

500

1

1

OoM (in setup stage)

500000

500

0.8

1

OoM (in setup stage)

500000

500

0.6

1

OoM (in setup stage)

500000

500

0.4

1

OoM (in setup stage)

500000

500

0.2

1

OoM (in setup stage)

500000

500

0.1

1

OoM (in setup stage)

500000

500

0.08

1

OoM (in setup stage)

500000

500

0.06

1

OoM (in setup stage)

500000

500

0.04

1

OoM (in setup stage)

500000

500

0.02

1

OoM (in setup stage)

500000

500

0.01

1

OoM (in setup stage)

500000

500

1

2

OoM (in setup stage)

500000

500

1

2

OoM (in setup stage)

500000

500

0.8

2

OoM (in setup stage)

500000

500

0.8

2

OoM (in setup stage)

500000

500

0.6

2

OoM (in setup stage)

500000

500

0.6

2

OoM (in setup stage)

500000

500

0.4

2

OoM (in setup stage)

500000

500

0.4

2

OoM (in setup stage)

500000

500

0.2

2

OoM (in setup stage)

500000

500

0.2

2

OoM (in setup stage)

500000

500

0.1

2

OoM (in setup stage)

500000

500

0.1

2

OoM (in setup stage)

500000

500

0.08

2

OoM (in setup stage)

500000

500

0.08

2

OoM (in setup stage)

500000

500

0.06

2

OoM (in setup stage)

500000

500

0.06

2

OoM (in setup stage)

500000

500

0.04

2

OoM (in setup stage)

500000

500

0.04

2

OoM (in setup stage)

500000

500

0.02

2

OoM (in setup stage)

500000

500

0.02

2

OoM (in setup stage)

500000

500

0.01

2

OoM (in setup stage)

500000

500

0.01

2

OoM (in setup stage)